Sean Nelson

The first official batch of recordings to bear the name of Seattle musician Sean Nelson isn’t a solo album in the classic sense. Make Good Choices includes playing/songwriting/recording contributions from, among others, Chris Walla (Death Cab for Cutie), Peter Buck (R.E.M./Minus 5), Matt Pence & Scott Danbom (Centro-Matic), Howard Draper (Shearwater), Dave Depper (Loch Lomond, Fruit Bats), Rachel Blumberg (Decemberists/M. Ward), Adam Selzer (Norfolk & Western), Steve Fisk (player: Pell Mell, Pigeonhed; producer: Nirvana, Beat Happening, Unwound), and others—with Nelson’s nonpareil lyrics, melodies, and voice unmistakably at the center. Sessions arose over the course of several years, between Nelson and his collaborators’ other projects, with no deadline, no master plan, and above all, no rush. The unorthodox process yielded great results, but required that he take the long view. When he realized he’d been taking it for nearly a decade, it was probably time to write a press release.

Sean Nelson is best known as the former lead singer of Seattle’s Harvey Danger, a Seattle indie pop band whose curious fortune it was to have a song from their debut album turn into a radio and MTV hit during the sharp intake of breath that separated the twilight of the dubious “alternative” era and the period when the internet arose from the ashes of the rock and roll Rome that burned down while Limp Bizkit fiddled. Harvey Danger’s song, “Flagpole Sitta,” was an out-of-nowhere anthem that can still be heard at karaoke bars, sports arenas, and one excellent British sitcom (to say nothing of non-ironic-seeming recent covers by Deer Tick and Beast Make Bomb and a landmark lip dub video that probably has more hits than the original) every day of the week, every week of the year, every year since 1998. Though the song’s success cast a long shadow over the rest of the band’s efforts, they did in the end find a loving and appreciative audience and a scale they could enjoy. Their four LPs were ambitious, influential, and deeply loved by a cult of devotees that continues to spread the word.

Rather than allow the aforementioned shadow (which, let’s be honest, contained a few perks) dim his enthusiasm for making and performing, Nelson has spent the past decade-plus pursuing musical and extra-musical endeavors. He has recorded with a bunch of great artists, including Death Cab for Cutie, Nada Surf, The Decemberists, The Minus 5, and Robyn Hitchcock & The Venus 3. A semi-regular performer at the prestigious L.A. club Largo—even when it was still on Fairfax—he has been a frequent guest singer at Jon Brion’s legendary Friday night improv shows in addition to his own appearances. (He even got called upon to sing harmonies on “Don’t Go Back to Rockville” onstage during R.E.M.’s last tour, which is a whole other story.) He co-founded The Long Winters in 2001 as a vehicle for John Roderick’s songs, co-producing their first album, performing on the second and third, and touring as the band’s keyboard player/harmony singer/wartime consigliere for its volatile first three years. He also hosted a show on KEXP for five years, wrote a 33&1/3 book about Joni Mitchell’s Court and Spark, and is a partner in Seattle’s Barsuk Records.

Along the way, Nelson also forged a sideline career in independent film. This work began auspiciously when Lynn Shelton (who would go on to direct Humpday, Your Sister’s Sister, and an episode of Mad Men) asked him to be the lead actor/co-writer/emotional centerpiece of her second feature film, My Effortless Brilliance. The film premiered at SXSW 2008, was a hit on the festival circuit, and was distributed by IFC. Nelson’s revealing, hyperverbal-but-heartfelt performance in Brilliance soon led to other memorable roles for up-and-coming auteurs—alongside Dax Shepard and Katie Aselton in Aselton’s The Freebie; in David Russo’s experimental The Immaculate Conception of Little Dizzle; Megan Griffiths’ The Off Hours, and, in Stephen Gyllenhaal’s Grassroots and Lynn Shelton’s MTV web series $5 Cover. But even as the NY Times called him an “indie darling” (on the very low end of the cinematic spectrum), music was always his main thing.

Which brings us back, inevitably, to Make Good Choices. The songs on Make Good Choices were written and recorded in fits and starts over the past several years when Nelson’s primary bands—first Harvey Danger and later The Long Winters—were, variously, not touring, on hiatus, or broken up. The project was abandoned and revived almost promiscuously, according to surges and lapses of confidence, vicissitudes of scheduling, and, of course, the dismal science of economy. (It’s a long story, but a good one.) Yet the songs stuck around, and as time went by, the material began to feel less like an accumulation of discrete sessions and more like an oddly organic collection unified by Nelson’s irrepressible pop instincts, razor sharp lyrics, and powerhouse voice. And so, yes: kind of a solo record, and kind of not, but more to the point a record—of smart, funny, sad, and true pop-rock songs that peer into the dark corners of the culture, the psyche, and the singer himself.